This "old" "favorite" in Savannah's Historic District has "stood the test of time" (along with the building, which was built in 1753) with its swashbuckling theme, "old pirate tunnels" and "stories" that "make it worth a stop" for some "family fun"; while there's some "first-rate" seafood to be found on the Continental menu, critics keelhaul the "touristy fare", and opt for "a drink at the bar" instead.